Killing Jesus, the bestselling blockbuster by Bill O’Reilly, claims to be a purely historical account of the events in the life of Jesus leading up to his crucifixion. New Testament scholar Robert M. Price (a member of the Jesus Seminar) shows how unfounded this claim is in this critical review of O’Reilly’s work. In fact, he judges the book to be the number one source of misinformation on Jesus today. Ignoring over one hundred years of New Testament scholarship, O’Reilly and his coauthor, Martin Dugard, have produced what Price describes as a Christian historical thriller that plays fast and loose with the facts.
Price goes through the key events of JesusÔÇÖ later life as described in the gospels and retold in Killing Jesus, painstakingly showing in each case what scholars know and donÔÇÖt know. Using humor, down-to-earth analogies, and witty sarcasmÔÇönot unlike OÔÇÖReillyÔÇÖs own interview styleÔÇöPrice makes it clear that OÔÇÖReillyÔÇÖs book is more historical novel than a work of serious history. By cobbling together the four gospel stories, ignoring the contradictions, and adding plenty of quasi-historical background embellishments, OÔÇÖReilly and Dugard have created a good narrative that resonates with a lot of Christians. Entertaining reading this may be, but history it is not.
Killing History provides lay readers with an accessible introduction to New Testament scholarship while showing the many problems in OÔÇÖReillyÔÇÖs book.
Review
ÔÇ£Robert M. Price does in Killing History what he does best: bring immense erudition, sharp critical thinking, and edgy humor to sort through a thorny topic in our public discourse about the Bible. In plain language, but without simplifying, Price expertly dissects the dilettante ÔÇÿargumentsÔÇÖ in OÔÇÖReillyÔÇÖs Killing Jesus, exposing it for the pretentious pablum that it is. Along the way, Price serves up a first-rate introduction to the academic historical-critical interpretation of the gospels.ÔÇØ
ÔÇöRobert J. Miller, fellow of the Jesus Seminar
ÔÇ£Even though serious and hard-hitting scholarship on the historical Jesus has been available for over three hundred years, modern writers continue to publish ÔÇÿpopularÔÇÖ accounts of JesusÔÇÖ words and deeds, blithely ignorant of what we actually know. In Killing History, New Testament scholar Robert Price shows that among the worst of sinners is Bill OÔÇÖReilly and his bestselling but ill-conceived book Killing Jesus. In point after point, Price convincingly and authoritatively argues that OÔÇÖReilly has produced a Jesus of his own imagination, rather than the Jesus who emerges from a historically informed study of the gospels.ÔÇØ
ÔÇö Bart D. Ehrman, James A. Gray Professor, Department of Religious Studies, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
ÔÇ£It is no secret that Bill OÔÇÖReilly and I disagree on various issues of church-state separation. OÔÇÖReilly told me that Christianity is a philosophy, not a religion, so government actions promoting Christianity are not against the Constitution; I think thatÔÇÖs just a disingenuous attempt to justify favoritism and religious bigotry. Robert M. Price now shows that the master of the ÔÇÿNo-Spin ZoneÔÇÖ also ÔÇÿmassages his factsÔÇÖ in his popular tome Killing Jesus. OÔÇÖReilly claims to be looking out for you, but heÔÇÖd better realize that Price is looking out for the truth.ÔÇØ
ÔÇöDavid Silverman, president of American Atheists
ÔÇ£For Robert M. Price, Bill OÔÇÖReillyÔÇÖs heart may sometimes be in the right place, but his head is not. Nor has he any more business writing a ÔÇÿhistoricalÔÇÖ book about Jesus than Sean Penn might to pontificate about foreign policy! Though Price may not believe there was a ÔÇÿhistorical Jesus,ÔÇÖ that does not mean he wants to see him abused and, for Price, that is what is going on in Killing Jesus. Killing History reveals Bill OÔÇÖReillyÔÇÖs claim that Killing Jesus is a ÔÇÿhistorical workÔÇÖ and not a religious one as blatant spinÔÇöso much so that, for Price, OÔÇÖReilly qualifies as a whirling dervish!ÔÇØ
ÔÇöRobert Eisenman, author of James the Brother of Jesus and The New Testament Code
About the Author
Robert M. Price is an adjunct professor of theology and scriptural studies at the Johnnie Colemon Theological Seminary, is the editor (with Jeffery Jay Lowder) of The Empty Tomb: Jesus Beyond the Grave and the Journal of Higher Criticism. He is also the author of Inerrant the Wind: The Evangelical Crisis of Biblical Authority; Top Secret: The Truth Behind TodayÔÇÖs Pop Mysticisms; The Paperback Apocalypse: How the Christian Church Was Left Behind; The Reason-Driven Life: What Am I Here on Earth For? and many other works.